Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Facebook

Share
Bombs for Butterflies
If the key to saving monarchs is growing more milkweed, why aren’t we walking around with pockets full of seed?

I’m here to tell you about a weapon that could change the world. It’s small, inexpensive, and easy to conceal. Discharging it in public wouldn’t harm any living creature; it wouldn’t even land you in jail. What it would do, believe it or not, is save millions of lives.

Butterfly lives.

Brothers and sisters, I speak of the milkweed seed bomb: a golf-ball-size grenade of dirt, clay and seeds that might just help salvage one of the most magnificent—and, in recent years, most endangered—wildlife migrations on Earth. Each year, millions of monarchs embark on a trek that spans the length of an entire continent, from Mexico to Canada—a distance of 2,400 miles. On the way north, the monarch population cycles through four generations. Going south, a single “supergeneration” makes the long trip.

But for the last two decades, fewer and fewer monarchs have been making it to their wintering grounds in the fir forests of Mexico’s Sierra Madre Mountains. Sure, the number of butterflies—33 million—that currently migrate south sounds like a lot. But the fluttering horde was at least one billion strong as recently as 1997.

Many scientists have theorized that deforestation is at the root of the population’s decline: as loggers have continued to remove trees from the Sierra Madres, cooler air has swept into the forests and killed the insects, which are sensitive enough to cold temperatures that they huddle together in great masses to conserve warmth. Other scientists blame agricultural pesticides in the United States and Canada that the monarchs encounter on their journey. Still other evidence seems to point the finger at extreme weather events as the main reason that so many butterflies are a no-show in Mexico.

But a recent study, published last month in the Journal of Animal Ecology, suggests a far simpler solution to this mysterious problem: We need more milkweed. Lots more milkweed. “Monarchs depend on milkweed plants,” says Tyler Flockhart, the study’s lead author and a conservation biologist at the University of Guelph. “Milkweed plants are declining. And that’s the main cause of monarch population declines.”

Flockhart and his coauthors have developed a sophisticated model that allows them to estimate the effects of habitat loss across the monarch’s entire range—from the butterfly’s wintering grounds in Mexico to its breeding grounds in the United States and Canada. But you don’t need to worry, as they do, about “stochastic and density-dependent periodic projection matrix models” to appreciate the importance of their findings.

You just need to worry about milkweed. It’s “the only plant monarchs lay their eggs on,” says Flockhart. “And it’s the only plant they’ll feed on as larva before they develop into butterflies.” Put very simply: As the milkweed goes, so do the monarchs.

“Milkweed,” by the way, is not a single species of plant, but rather a sizeable group of plants—73 species of which are native to North America. It’s capable of growing across a wide variety of habitats and conditions, but as our landscapes fill up with ever more suburbs and cities, fewer patches of wild land exist for milkweed—resilient though it may be—to hang its white, wispy hat.

Not helping matters at all are crops that have been genetically modified to resist pesticides, or “RoundUp-ready.” Such crops allow farmers to apply even more of the herbicide glyphosate (sold commercially under the name “RoundUp”) to their fields, causing huge swaths of land—especially in the “Breadbasket” of the Midwest—to become lethal to milkweed plants. When migrating monarchs stop off in these fields during an egg-laying layover, there’s nothing there for them to lay their eggs on.

For its part, the Natural Resources Defense Council (which publishes OnEarth) filed a petition earlier this year asking the Environmental Protection Agency to complete a new review of glyphosates, something the agency hasn’t done since 1993. According to Rebecca Riley, an NRDC attorney specializing in wildlife issues, a new evaluation of the herbicide is necessary, since farmers—thanks to RoundUp-ready crops—apply much more glyphosate on their land than they did two decades ago. Among other things, Riley suggests that the EPA should restrict the use of glyphosate on roadsides, create and enforce buffer zones around farms to prevent runoff, and set aside land for milkweed cultivation.

Those are all great suggestions, every one of them. But why wait around on slow federal machinery when you’ve got a milkweed bomb burning a hole in your pocket?

“The whole basis of the monarch’s occurrence in North America is based on the migration, and the fact that there’s supposed to be milkweed all over the place,” says Andy Warren, a lepidopterist and collections manager at the McGuire Center for Lepidoptera & Biodiversity. “So, really, anything anybody can do to put more milkweed out there is good.”

Cue the bombs.

So-called guerrilla gardeners have been launching seed bombs into vacant or dilapidated urban lots for years. Building them is easy: make a tiny mud pie out of dirt, clay, and milkweed seed—making sure to use only seeds that are native to your area and that haven’t been treated with any kind of pesticide. Then just play a little game of patty-cake to shape the pies into projectiles, let them dry for a bit in the sun, and lob the mud globs onto any patch of land that makes sense. (Highway medians, ditches, and gravel patches beside railroad tracks are all good candidates. Private office parks, secure facilities, and your neighbors’ flower garden are not.)

In short, it’s time to get creative. That’s what Jenny Kendler, a Chicago-based artist and monarch maven has done. At the end of July, Kendler (now an NRDC artist-in-residence) plans to hand out fully biodegradable balloons, pre-filled with fluffy milkweed seeds, to passersby in St. Louis. (Why St. Louis? Maybe it has something to do with the fact that a certain glysophate-inventing multinational is headquartered there.)

Upon receipt of a balloon, Kendler will be encouraging St. Louisians to pop it in a suitable location that’s near and dear to them, personally—releasing the milkweed seeds to the wind.

Like this article? Donate to NRDC to support OnEarth's groundbreaking nonprofit journalism.

image of Jason Bittel
OnEarth news blogger Jason Bittel contributes to Slate and serves up science for picky eaters on his website, Bittel Me This. He lives in Pittsburgh with his wife and two tiny wolves. (Note: wolves may be Pomeranians.) MORE STORIES ➔
Comments (13)
Reader comments are moderated and may be edited or deleted if they violate our rules for civil discourse.
All comments offered in the spirit of civil discourse are welcome. Commercial spam, obscenity, and other rude behavior are not and will be removed. Due to our nonprofit status, we are also required to delete any express or implied statement endorsing or opposing any political party or candidate for political office. Valid email addresses are required. (OnEarth respects your privacy and will not use, lend, or sell your email address for any reason.)
Why aren't we preserving and restoring prairie? Particularly in the northern Plains where most overwintering monarchs come from. Let's look at economic pressures that privilege a monoculture of corn that go not to feed us, but cattle and gas tanks. It's about prairie, not just one plant in the prairie.
Stop your whining. You absolutely turn people off.
Your comment is not necessary. I agree we need to save the prairies.
I'm disturbed that NRDC, a group I've been a member of for years, is espousing the indiscriminate distribution of milkweed seeds with apparently no consideration for sewing seeds in areas appropriate for the species being distributed. I'm concerned that the sewing of non-native seed might have a negative impact on local species. This concern is even stronger when it comes to the "seed bombing" of America. What species are we spreading and what will there impacts be. Some of our most irascible invasive species got started with the best of intentions, but a lack of insight into potential long-term effects. You want to encourage the spread of milkweed seed? Than make sure you're spreading seed native to the area you're spreading it.
Since the article specifically requests that you only use seeds native to your area, your complaint makes no sense.
Like
My community is planting a field of flowers for pollinators. I understand it takes special equipment to sow them. This article doesn't explore what it takes to make milkweed seeds grow. I have spread thousands of milkweed seeds in my garden and have gotten no result. I've had more luck growing it in the loose gravel beside the road and on the high banks of ponds. The seeds must be cold stratified to reproduce. I've tried taking cuttings and haven't had much luck with that either. I applaud this effortless effort insofar as it can promote awareness of the issues, but I fear this problem is more complicated than we know. We've undone many millenia of nature's processes this time.
My neighborhood is planting a field of flowers for pollinators. I understand it takes special equipment to sow them. This article doesn't explore what it takes to make milkweed seeds grow. I have spread literally thousands of milkweed seeds in my garden and have gotten no result. I've had more luck growing it in the loose gravel beside the road and on the high banks of ponds. The seeds must be cold stratified to reproduce. I've tried taking cuttings and haven't had much luck with that either. I applaud this effortless effort insofar as it can promote awareness of the issues, but I fear this problem is more complicated than we know. We've undone many millenia of nature's processes this time. Planting milkweeds it nice. Don't get me wrong. Why would you take precious seeds away from a site where they are successful to a place where they aren't currently growing? With only 3% of the plants left in the field producing, we really don't have the luxury of experimenting on a large scale. The idea that there is always more no longer applies.
Wonderful information about milkweed and ways to distribute it. What the heck is Benjamin whining about? Such a downer.
Think it through http://www.alligator.org/opinion/columns/article_98ecb59e-df4b-11e0-9079-001cc4c03286.html?mode=print "Turtles don't celebrate with balloons, and neither do birds. In fact, balloons are responsible for killing most of the marine food chain, including sea turtles, dolphins, whales, birds and any other curious animal."
I love this idea! Here's a directory for locating milkweed seeds across the country: http://www.xerces.org/milkweed-seed-finder
Thank you for this information. I am not an expert on milkweed and do not want to accidentally spread an invasive plant. Most gardeners in my area think I'm loony for wanting to grow what many consider a weed. It helps to be able to order from a trusted source.
Good to read this! We have asked the farmer that cuts our hay to go around and not cut a large patch of milkweed in one of our fields. About a 1/2 acre. In previous years many monarchs have come and gone from this patch. It's small but if we all do a little, it will help these beautiful creatures.